Get this: Vietnam, a country of 97 million people, has reported zero deaths from only 372 cases of coronavirus.

Theories abound about how they pulled it off. But public health experts chalk it up to swift action by the Vietnamese government, including contact tracing, mass testing, lockdowns, and compulsory wearing of masks.

Here, masks have become a political landmine. And despite President Trump claiming, “We have the greatest testing program anywhere in the world,” some states with surging infections have testing shortages—like Arizona.

But what about contact tracing, the process of calling potentially exposed people and persuading them to quarantine?

“I don’t think we’re doing very well,” said Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, when asked in June about contact tracing nationwide. Most states haven’t even made public how fast or well they’re implementing the process, if at all.

Florida, the nation’s current No. 1 hotspot for the virus, is often failing to trace positive cases. This, despite the state spending over $27 million on a contract with Maximus, a company notorious for underbidding, understaffing, and performing poorly on government services contracts in multiple states.

Yet, there are bright spots elsewhere. California allocated 5 percent of staff across 90 state government departments to contact trace. North Carolina’s Wake County trained 110 librarians. In Massachusetts, counties have used state pandemic funds to hire more nurses.

There are three reasons why state and local governments should reassign public employees or hire new staff outright as the country—finally—ramps up contact tracing.

One, outsourcing what should be a public job to for-profit companies like Maximus reduces transparencylimits democratic decision-makinglowers service quality, and increases inequality, all while rarely saving public dollars. Public control is particularly important when it comes to contact tracing, which involves personal health data.

Two, this is a chance to begin to reverse decades of cuts to public health budgets, which have made the worst public health crisis in a century even worse. Almost a quarter of the local public health workforce has been let go since 2008. Federal spending on nondefense discretionary programs like public health is now at a historic low.

The Trump administration, as expected, is headed in the wrong direction. On Tuesday, it stripped the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) of control over coronavirus data. State and local governments must do all they can to right the ship.

And three, contact tracing is an opportunity to chip away at systemic racism. Since World War II, public sector employment has helped equalize American society by offering workers of color stable, well-paid employment. The median wage earned by Black employees is significantly higher in the public sector than in private industries.

Privatizing public work like contact tracing contributes to racial and gender income disparities. Workers at federal call centers operated by Maximus, for example, are predominately women and people of color paid poverty wages as low as $10.80 an hour with unaffordable health care.

If #BlackLivesMatter—as many governors and mayors across the country have proclaimed in recent weeks—then contact tracing should be treated as what it is: a public good.

To catch up to other countries like Vietnam, the U.S. needs to get contact tracing right—and that means doing it with public workers.

More on making government work for all of us:

  • “A public safety reimagining process.” Officials in Berkeley, California, have voted to create a new transportation department with a racial justice lens and assign crisis responders (rather than police) to respond to non-criminal calls, among other changes. Berkeleyside
  • How schools have responded. A study has found that traditional, neighborhood public schools have outperformed privately operated charter schools in providing services to disadvantaged students during the COVID-19 crisis. National Center for Research on Education Access and Choice
  • “Judeo-Christian principles” to be taught at new charter school. A charter school set to open in California’s Orange County will teach students based on the “traditions of Western Civilization … embracing the Judeo-Christian principles as expressed by the founders of America.” Students and teachers will not be required to wear masks. California Globe
  • Not “free money.” A study has revealed that Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan’s controversial plan to use a public-private partnership to add toll lanes to multiple highways could require the public to chip in as much as $1 billion. The Washington Post
  • Did you know? After the Civil War, Black Americans in the South abolished property qualifications for voting and officeholding and opened the region’s first public schools, making them available to all children, among other efforts to expand democracy. Retweet this


This is Pro-Public, an email newsletter for people who think government should work for all of us—produced by In the Public Interest.

Not a subscriber? Sign up for these emails here.

Related Posts